• MSN
  • Hotmail
  • More
    • Autos
    • My MSN
    • Video
    • Careers & Jobs
    • Personals
    • Weather
    • Delish
    • Quotes
    • White Pages
    • Games
    • Real Estate
    • Wonderwall
    • Horoscopes
    • Shopping
    • Yellow Pages
    • Local Edition
    • Traffic
    • Feedback
    • Maps & Directions
    • Travel
    • Full MSN Index
  • Bing
  • msnbc.com sites & shows:
  • TODAY
  • Rock Center
  • Nightly News
  • Meet the Press
  • Dateline
  • Morning Joe
  • Hardball
  • Ed
  • Maddow
  • Last Word
  • msnbc tv
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Food
  • Health
  • Money
  • Travel
  • Books
  • Pets
  • Parenting
  • Style
  • KLG & Hoda
  • Blogs
    • allDAY
    • Animal Tracks
    • Bites
    • The Clicker
    • Digital Life
    • Hip2Save
    • Kathie Lee & Hoda
    • Life Inc.
    • The Look
    • Scoop
    • TODAY Entertainment
    • TODAY Health
    • TODAY Moms
    • TODAY Travel
  • More
    • Comics & Games
    • Concert Series
    • Good News!
    • Horoscope
    • Lotto
    • Photo Features
    • Relationships
    • The Royals
    • Tech
    • TODAY at 60
    • Weather
    • Weddings
  • Recommended: Have you and your spouse ever competed for the same job?
  • Recommended: For women in the workplace, it's still about looks not deeds
  • Recommended: Where are all the powerful female nerds?
  • Recommended: It's me or the cafeteria food: Creative reasons for quitting

Life Inc. is about how the economy is affecting you: your life, your job, your family, your finances, your spending. Check us out on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.
  • ↓ About this blog
  • ↓ Archives
    • Icons Email E-mail updates
    • Icons Twitter Follow on Twitter
    • Icons Feed Subscribe to RSS
  • Advertise | AdChoices
    18
    Apr
    2012
    2:18pm, EDT

    Affording college tuition may mean having to wait

    Farnoosh Torabi

    By Eve Tahmincioglu

    This is the season when college acceptance letters start coming in the mail and lots of families are trying to figure out how to pay the hefty tuition costs.

    With annual in-state tuition costs for public colleges averaging more than $8,000, and private school costs topping $28,000, reports CollegeBoard.org, the thought of covering such an expense can seem hopeless, especially to parents facing budget constraints already.

    But never fear, stressed Farnoosh Torabi, personal finance expert, author of “Psych Yourself Rich: Get the Mindset and Discipline You Need to Build Your Financial Life”, and host of "Financially Fit" on Yahoo, who was on hand Wednesday to take online questions from readers during our weekly live chat.

    “There is hope if you're willing to be flexible and not rush into the whole college thing,” she said.

    “Saving money takes preparation and it takes thinking outside of the box,” she explained. “I will be the first to say that your child doesn't need to head to college right away - especially if the money isn't there. Taking a year off to work, save or enhance your resume with volunteering experiences can boost your chances of not only getting into a good school, but paying for it.”

    For those who don’t want to wait, she said, two-year community colleges can be a good starting point. “Smart, talented students are flocking to community college to earn credits, save money and later move over to a full-time 4 year institution,” she noted.

    Torabi also weighed in on the question of whether parents should be saving at all for their kids’ education, a topic covered by reporter Allison Linn Wednesday. 

    “Some parents see college as a great gift to their children - and if you feel strongly about making this a financial priority, that's great,” she said. “But don't kill yourself trying to send your children to college. Do what you can. Be realistic and involve your kids in the reality. One thing is true, when children bear some of the cost, they tend to appreciate the education more and recognize the value a lot more.”

    You can read the full Q&A with Torabi here:

     

    5 comments

    The community college thing might be a good thing in some states but the community colleges barely exist in my state. My son went to a community college after he moved to another state, and my understanding is that every single class he took there transferred to their state universities which are al …

    Show more
    Explore related topics: money, college, tuition, geny
  • 7
    Mar
    2012
    11:27am, EST

    Paychecks for young adults getting slimmer

    By Eve Tahmincioglu

    Young adults may be facing their own version of “The Hunger Games” when entering the workforce today because they’re probably going to be hungry for more money.

    Wages for young workers have been declining for more than a decade. They fell off a cliff during the Great Recession to levels not seen since the 1970s for certain groups of entry-level workers, according to new data from center-left think tank the Economic Policy Institute.

    (OK, maybe it’s not exactly “The Hunger Games” just yet. In that dystopian future, depicted in a trilogy of novels and now a movie, a reality TV show follows teens fighting to their death, with the winner earning food for his/her home state. But you get our point.)

    Not surprisingly, the news is worse for those with less education; and the pay gap between entry level men and women no matter what the education level is still alive and well.

    Entry-level wages for high school graduates were actually lower than they were in the 1970s. For college grads, starting wages were below what their counterparts pocketed in the late 1990s. Today, the average wage for all these young adults, no matter education level, is about $15 an hour.

    And whether they have a college degree or not, women still aren’t bringing home as much bacon as the men, but the gap has been narrowing. The good news, unfortunately, is partly attributable to the fact that the guys are getting paid less because of the economy.

    “When the labor market is strong for workers the prospects for young workers are very strong, and when the labor market is weak their prospects are very weak,” maintained the Institute’s president Lawrence Mishel about the data that’s part of his forthcoming book ‘The State of Working America” due out in August. “The recent decade affirms this general finding, as the wages of entry-level workers have fared extremely poorly during this period of general wage stagnation.”

    Here’s a breakdown of the numbers:

    • The entry-level hourly wage of a young male high school graduate in 2011 was 25.3 percent less than that for the equivalent worker in 1979, a drop of roughly $4.00 per hour in 2011.
    • Among women, the entry-level high school wage fell 14.2 percent over the same period, and dropped by $1.64 last year.
    • Wages for high-school educated women are still far below those of their male counterparts, a gap of 15 percent.
    • In 2011 the hourly wage of entry-level male college graduates was just a bit over $1.00 higher than in 1979, a rise of 5.2 percent over thirty-two years.
    • Women college grads did better, with their wages growing by 15.4 percent, or $2.50, from 1979 to 2011.
    • The gender pay gap among this group, however, still persists. The hourly wage for college educated men was $21.68 in 2011, compared with $18.80 for women.

    Too bad young adults don't qualify for child ticket prices anymore. Adult tickets for the upcoming "The Hunger Games" movie are going for $11 a pop.

     

    387 comments

    One big reason for lower entry-level wages is, I believe, the lack of manufacturing jobs which tended to pay well. The "service" and "information" sectors tend to pay less.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: jobs, college, pay, wages, gen-y
  • 17
    Nov
    2011
    2:34pm, EST

    Yes, college degree has value -- try $1 million

    Census Bureau

    By Martin Wolk

    The Census Bureau has taken a new stab at answering the age-old question: Just how much is a college degree worth?

    The answer: $1 million.

    That is a rough average, of course, but data collected in an extensive Bureau study suggests that a college degree is worth about $1 million in additional lifetime earnings compared with a comparable worker with only a high school diploma.

    Based on 2008 data, full-time workers with a bachelor’s degree had median earnings of $57,000, compared with $34,000 for workers with only a high school diploma.

    That adds up.

    For example, white men with a bachelor’s degree who work full-time can expect to make more than  $2.8 million over their 40-year working lifetime, compared with $1.7 million for white men with only a high school diploma, for a difference of $1.1 million. White women with a bachelor’s degree will make about $2 million over their working lifetimes, compared with about $1.2 million for white women who go no further than high school.

    A Census Bureau news release said the average lifetime difference for a bachelor’s degree vs. a high school diploma was $1 million.

    The results were based on data collected from 2006 to 2008 and were presented in 2008 dollars.

    The report shows a “clear and well-defined relationship between education and earnings,” even after considering demographic and other characteristics, write authors Tiffany Julian and Robert Kominski.

    While white men generally get the biggest advantage from higher education, all races benefit from advanced study, according to the report. Black men, for example, will make nearly $800,000 more over their working lifetime if they go beyond high school and attain a college degree.

    A master’s degree typically adds about $500,000 to lifetime earnings, according to the report, while a professional degree in medicine or law can easily add another $1 million on top of that.

    Census Bureau

    White men typically earn more than any other demographic groups, but Asian men are not far behind and are even or ahead at the master’s level and above.

    Women at virtually every level make considerably less than comparably educated men, the study confirms. White women, for example, typically earn about 70 percent of what white men earn over their lifetimes, although the gap narrows substantially for women with doctorate degrees.

    The report also shows that while 85 percent of adults have high-school diplomas, fewer than 30 percent have college degrees.

    Just as a reminder, the current average “sticker price” for a college education, including tuition, fees, room and board, is $16,000 a year at an in-state public university and $37,000 at a private school.

    So, is a college education worth it?

    A look at whether colleges will soon compete on pricing, with Edwin Welch, University of Charleston president.

     

     

    157 comments

    So this article would have us all believe that the only life worth living is a life that makes the most money? Trade skills and artistic endeavors aren't worthwhile because they won't make us rich? What a pathetic thing to believe.

    Show more
    Explore related topics: education, personal-finance, featured, careers, college, featu
  • 30
    Sep
    2011
    7:29am, EDT

    Good Graph Friday: Going to college, but never getting a diploma

    Complete College America

    Follow @alinnmsnbc
    By Allison Linn

    The stereotypical idea of going to college is to leave home, move into a dorm, attending class full-time and send at least a chunk of the bills to Mom and Dad.

    A new report from an organization called Complete College America finds that that stereotype is the exception, not the rule.

    Instead, Complete College says, about three-fourths of U.S. college students these days are commuting from off campus, and they are often also juggling family and/or work responsibilities in addition to their classes.

    About 40 percent are going part-time, according to the advocacy group, which is working to increase the number of Americans with a college degree. Part-time students are less likely to ever get their diploma, even when given more time than full-time students, they find.

    The research is based on data provided by 33 states, including California, Ohio, Indiana and Massachusetts.

    The report comes as Americans increasingly struggle with two big issues: How to pay for the rising cost of college, and how to regain the nation’s economic momentum.

    Despite the burden of finding time and money for college, many do still think it’s a key way to get ahead in life.

    The unemployment rate for people with a college degree or higher was 4.3 percent in August, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. For people with just a high school degree, the unemployment rate was 9.6 percent.

    What’s to be done? Complete College recommends a number of steps designed to make it easier for people to juggle school and work, such as scheduling classes at predictable times and allowing for more work to be done online. They also recommend finding ways to get people through college faster.

     Related:

    You girls need an education!

    What's rising faster than health care costs? College costs

    What's the point of college? 

     

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: education, featured, college, good-graph-friday
  • 17
    Aug
    2011
    1:18pm, EDT

    You girls need an education!

    Pew Research Center

    By Allison Linn

    Perhaps it’s a good thing young women are getting college degrees at higher rates than men, because Americans seem to think women need that degree more.

    A new survey from the Pew Research Center finds that 77 percent of Americans think women need a college education to get ahead in life, while only 68 percent think that’s true about men.

    The data was part of a survey looking at how men and women perceive the value and benefits of college, and comes as the gap between young men and women completing a college degree continues to widen.

    According to Pew, in 2010 36 percent of women ages 25 to 29 had completed a bachelor’s degree. That compares with 28 percent of men in that age group.

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: education, featured, college, gender
  • 16
    Aug
    2011
    8:32pm, EDT

    Cheapism: The best sites to buy textbooks

    AP

    The first rule for finding cheap textbooks: Don't go to the bookstore.

    By Kara Reinhardt
    Cheapism.com

    For college students, back-to-school often means an expensive trip to the campus bookstore. The average cost of books and supplies at a four-year public university last year was $1,137, according to the College Board. Savvy students can save money by shopping online at specialized college textbook sites, which claim to offer savings of up to 90 percent. These sites also offer e-textbook downloads for Kindles, iPads, and other e-readers. Students can either rent or buy the books they need. While renting tends to be cheaper, buying is better for those who want to be able to refer back to a book after a course is over or add yellow highlights with abandon. Like bricks-and-mortar bookstores, textbook websites will often buy back books at the end of the term, provided they are still in good condition — typically for far less than the purchase price, of course.

    When you shop for anything online, shipping costs can cut into the savings. Some textbook sites offer free shipping if you spend over a certain amount. Return shipping factors in as well if you’re renting or planning to sell books back to a site. Be sure to order ASAP so you’ll have your books in time to start classes.

    Most sites offer both new and used books; the better the condition, the higher the price. If you opt for the cheapest books, be prepared for bent corners and doodles in the margins. Many sites also note that they can’t guarantee a used textbook will come with all the original supplemental materials, such as CDs.

    A broad selection can allow you to order books for all your classes in one place. A large inventory also makes it easier to find enough books to hit the minimum amount required for free shipping. However, many sites use third-party sellers — aka other students — to widen their selection, which can make them somewhat less reliable.

    Here are Cheapism’s top picks for college textbooks sites.

    • Textbook rental site Chegg.com offers 2.4 million titles and gives students the option to send books back for free or buy them at the end of the term. Students can also buy and sell books. The site holds renters accountable for the books’ condition upon return, so it may not be the best choice for copious highlighters, but it earns positive reviews for providing books that look like new. Users also praise the site’s customer service. (Where to buy)
    • Textbooks.com boasts a selection of 7 million books to buy or rent and offers free shipping on orders of $25 or more. User reviews often cite Textbooks.com as the cheapest option, and the site itself promises up to 90 percent off. Customers also applaud a redesign that makes it easy to find the best deal. (Where to buy)
    • ECampus.com offers not just textbooks but regular books, DVDs, Blue-ray discs, and college apparel. The site’s textbook inventory comes from a network of third-party sellers, making it susceptible to complaints about delinquent deliveries. Shipping is free for rental returns and orders over $59. (Where to buy)

    More from Cheapism:

    Cheap College Textbooks
    Cheap Smartphones
    Cheap Kids Clothes
     
    Best Cheap Laptops

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: featured, college, textbooks, cheapism
  • 11
    Aug
    2011
    8:35pm, EDT

    Good Graph Friday: What's rising faster than health care? College costs

    Moody's Analytics

    By Allison Linn

    Everyone knows that the cost of health care has become a bigger and bigger burden in recent years, but even that pales in comparison to another skyrocketing cost: College.

    The folks at Moody’s Analytics crunched some government numbers and found that the cost of tuition and fees has more than doubled since 2000. That’s a bigger percentage increase than, well, pretty much anything else.

    Given a chart like this, it’s no wonder we view college as overpriced and unaffordable – but still worth it for the professional and other advantages.

    Still, there is a downside to such a pricey education: Debt. The Moody’s paper notes that student loan balances also have risen steadily in recent years, leaving many students starting out their careers with a hefty chunk of money to pay off.

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: education, health-care, featured, college, debt, good-graph-friday
  • 11
    Aug
    2011
    11:11am, EDT

    Parents rich? You may have to pitch in for college anyway

    By Anika Anand

    Just because your parents are wealthy doesn't mean they will sign for all your college bills. 

    Nearly half of affluent parents did not or will not pay the full cost of their children's college education, according to Bank of America's latest Merrill Lynch Affluent Insights Survey.

    The most commonly cited reason was not that they couldn't afford it but that their kids either got a grant or scholarship or were expected to. But many parents said they were making their children pay part of the cost to give them "a greater appreciation for their education" or "teach them about financial responsibility."

    And 18 percent of affluent parents said they didn't or wouldn't have the money to pay the full freight. The Affluent Insights Survey reaches individuals with at least $250,000 in "investable assets," which these days might fund one student in a fancy private college, but not more than that.

    Despite the stated desire to teach children financial wisdom, 82 percent said they would support their children financially during their early adult years by allowing them to move back home (with or without rent) or by subsidizing their living expenses.

    The study also found that nearly half of affluent parents (48 percent) were more concerned about teaching their children financial responsibility than they were about their children finding the right spouse/partner, choosing the right career path or staying physically fit.

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: education, featured, parenting, college
  • 21
    Jun
    2011
    8:12am, EDT

    They're kind of a big deal ... just ask them

    By Rob Neill

    From the “they needed a study for this?” dept.:  Undergrad biz majors need to get over themselves.

    The Harvard Business Review reports on a recent study that showed business majors scored much higher than psychology students in an index that measured how narcissistic they are. No word on why they decided to compare them to the psych students.

    Far be it from us to pass judgment on the kids. Maybe they’re just preparing for the real world.

    "Our future business leaders appear to be even more self-absorbed and entitled" than other students not in business school, the researchers reported.

    Sounds like our current business leaders.

    Comment

    Show more
    Explore related topics: featured, college, business-school, snowflakes, alex-keaton
  • 17
    Jun
    2011
    8:22am, EDT

    Good Graph Friday: What's the point of college?

    Pew Research Center

    By Allison Linn

    There’s been plenty of talk lately about the cost of college, and whether it’s worth it.  But here’s another interesting question: What’s the main purpose of a college?

    It turns out, we’re pretty divided on this point.

    The Pew Research Center surveyed about 2,000 Americans and found that 47 percent think the main purpose of college is to teach work-related skills and knowledge. But 39 percent say the main purpose of college is intellectual and personal growth. About 12 percent said the years we spend at an institute of higher learning should be devoted to both.

    Interestingly, those with more education are more likely to view college as a place for personal and intellectual growth.

    What do you think the purpose of college is?

    Results with 94 short comments
    Total of 12,325 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

    14.2%
    Acquiring specific skills and knowledge
    1,752 votes
    19%
    Intellectual growth
    2,346 votes
    66.8%
    Both
    8,227 votes
    Display Comments:
    Intellectual growth

    Not only is it ideal for college to be about intellectual growth but is pragmatic as most will not end up with jobs in their major.

    • 1 vote
    #1
     - EmilyinIowa
     - 10:08 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
    Both

    Worked for me!

      #2
       - Alan in AZ
       - 10:14 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      The #1 purpose of college is to acquire and use critical thinking skills. Without this the rest of your education will be wasted.

      • 9 votes
      #3
       - Robert NOLA
       - 10:15 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Intellectual growth

      It's only the lack of degree that is helpful. Helpful to employers who can eliminate you without any further thought. Good for networking.

      • 5 votes
      #4
       - citizen1
       - 10:16 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Intellectual growth

      In many cases what your degree is in does not matter - just that you have a degree.

      • 7 votes
      #5
       - princessbride
       - 10:16 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Acquiring specific skills and knowledge

      A good place to put you in DEBT for LIFE

      • 12 votes
      #6
       - Edmond-903592
       - 10:21 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      Jobs come and go. If one only focuses on today's needs, you will be more vulnerable. Learn to be a flexible, adaptable learner.

      • 3 votes
      #7
       - DIANAinIOWA
       - 10:28 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      No matter how you spin it - they can repo your house, car, belongings but not your education. And without an education you don't have a job

      • 1 vote
      #8
       - Kelly-505114
       - 10:37 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      It SHOULD be acquiring specific skills & knowledge. Intellectual growth should be a mere side effect.

      • 4 votes
      #9
       - Anne-297812
       - 10:37 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      I'm of blue collar stock, so college is prep for better work/money. A friend from an affluent family is comfy w/ educ. for educ's sake.

      • 1 vote
      #10
       - GK-298121
       - 10:39 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Intellectual growth

      For the first couple years after you graduate, it might matter what you majored in. After that, all that matters is that you HAVE a degree.

      • 1 vote
      #11
       - Jay Fox
       - 10:40 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      But it's up to YOU to make your time there well spent. You can either have a great education, or you can waste your time for a junk degree

      • 3 votes
      #12
       - su-314019
       - 10:40 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      it's important to gain knowledge and marketable skills, but learning to socialize is as big a part of the educational process. You need bot

      • 1 vote
      #13
       - B.Roy
       - 10:50 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Intellectual growth

      College is a waste of time and money currently . No preparation for real life occurs in a university .

      • 10 votes
      #14
       - mercenary76
       - 10:52 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Acquiring specific skills and knowledge

      If you are in a technical field (like I am) that is why you are there. However if you are in Liberal Arts....

      • 6 votes
      #15
       - Hexdragon-111
       - 10:58 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      It should be for both, but higher education today has become a farce.

      • 6 votes
      #16
       - Penny3333
       - 10:59 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
      Both

      The point of college is to prove you can FINISH something you started, whatever the skills set you learn might be.

        #17
         - T. in TN
         - 11:02 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
        Both

        The skills open the career door. The intellectual growth allows the career to flourish, not stagnate.

        • 2 votes
        #18
         - Goat Rancher Bob
         - 11:02 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
        Both

        As you acquire specific skills and knowledge, you are not growing personally and intellectually? Did the authors of this study go to colleg

          #19
           - Mark-515467
           - 11:04 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
          Both

          Just to get the paper to get you in the door. Sure doesn't make you any smarter.

          • 6 votes
          #20
           - Coyote-2251386
           - 11:10 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
          Both

          They didn't mention college as a way of "joining a club", one that excludes non-members especially in hiring practices, Common, NOT illegal

          • 5 votes
          #21
           - K.C. Albak-2771046
           - 11:10 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
          Both

          It's nice to expand your horizons, but you've got to be practical too. Four years is a small part of the rest of your life.

            #22
             - Catzenjammer
             - 11:11 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
            Both

            Opponents of education-devaluing college education-- keep citizens uneducated so they will vote against their own best interests!

              #23
               - nurse-1006475
               - 11:19 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
              Both

              It's hard to say anymore if it's worth it. Most US jobs go oversees anyway thanks to Dell and HP (Carly baby!).

              • 5 votes
              #24
               - drushalli
               - 11:24 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
              Both

              The purpose of college education is to learn the skill and habit of continue education oneself, always self-motivated.

                #25
                 - Waleey
                 - 11:34 am EDT on Fri Jun 17, 2011
                Jump to short comment page: 1 2 3 4

                Comment

                Show more
                Explore related topics: education, featured, college, pew, good-graph-friday
              • 25
                May
                2011
                4:31pm, EDT

                The entrepreneur who's paying kids not to go to college

                Peter Thiel

                By Allison Linn

                There’s been a lot of talk recently about whether it’s worth it to go to college, given the high cost and potentially heavy student loan burden that comes with that diploma.

                Now, an entrepreneur has launched a fellowship that aims to test that theory by paying people not to go to school.

                The co-founder of online pocketbook PayPal, Peter Thiel, on Wednesday announced the winners of a fellowship that will pay nearly two dozen students $100,000 not to attend college for two years.

                The catch? (There’s always a catch.) The 20 Under 20 Thiel Fellowship winners have to spend the time working on their scientific and technical innovations. They’ll be aided by a host of high-profile advisors who will teach the kids about disruptive technologies, mentor them and provide support and training (but don’t call it school!).

                These aren’t just any 20 people, of course.

                The foundation’s website said the winners include Andrew Hsu, who started at the University of Washington at age 12 and was, at age 19, pursuing his Ph.D. at Stanford when he left to work on his startup.

                Darren Zhu is dropping out of Yale to pursue his interest in synthetic biology, and 19-year-old Eden Full has already founded a solar energy startup. Laura Deming enrolled at MIT at age 14 and is working on ways to extend the human lifespan by hundreds of years.

                Thiel announced the fellowship plan last fall, in a press release packed with quotes from tech luminaries who extolled the virtues of dropping out.

                Thiel himself seems fairly convinced that his experiment could change the world – or at least empower someone else to. In a statement announcing the contest last fall, he noted some of the major technologies that had been developed by people who dropped out of school, and predicted that his group would do the same.

                “The Thiel fellows will change the world and call it a senior thesis,” he said in the statement.

                 

                Do you think these fellowships are a stunt, or a real attempt to debate the merits of a college education?

                Results with 45 short comments
                Total of 7,163 votes - click on the "Display Comments" bar below to sort comments

                30.9%
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college
                2,216 votes
                61.4%
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students
                4,397 votes
                7.7%
                It's too early to tell
                550 votes
                Display Comments:
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                This is a sham because you'll notice that only students who are citizens of other countries will be. It doesn't represent American Students

                • 2 votes
                #26
                 - wolfe426
                 - 5:17 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                These are not "normal" college students. That said, too many kids use college as a excuse to stay drunk for 4+ years and avoid growing up.

                • 4 votes
                #27
                 - howitis-1710173
                 - 5:18 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's too early to tell

                Some of these 20 somethings will do tatoo or bong design. LOL Fire the college President's for this serious over pricing.

                • 2 votes
                #28
                 - Yank-957120
                 - 5:42 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                I think college is overrated. I'm in debt up to my eyeballs and no it wasn't worth it.

                • 10 votes
                #29
                 - Brenda-251440
                 - 5:47 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                Though a stunt, it does help spark an important debate at a time of skyrocketing educational costs.

                • 4 votes
                #30
                 - RonInColorado
                 - 5:55 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                Some of these "kids" already have advanced degrees. And they'll get 50K a year to avoid college for 2 years, not forever. This is a stunt!

                • 5 votes
                #31
                 - ChrisMcK
                 - 6:02 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                One has MIT degree, another was working on PhD? This should have been offered to HS grads or students not done with their Bachelors yet.

                • 9 votes
                #32
                 - Acharabelle
                 - 6:21 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                Let's use an average student. Not someone that already has more education that most of the US. These kids are exceptional and not the rule.

                • 7 votes
                #33
                 - Paddleboard-1959058
                 - 6:43 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                It's a great program, if you happen to be a genius!

                • 4 votes
                #34
                 - su-314019
                 - 7:15 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                The years lost may not be regained by most individual students, as these are the most impressionable in life.

                • 1 vote
                #35
                 - Jaya Sarma Gujral
                 - 8:27 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                It ia a great way to start debate about the value of college but yes these people don't represent most students, through in a few regulars.

                • 4 votes
                #36
                 - JP. Toronto
                 - 9:05 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                Student loan bubble will be the next big bubble to burst. Big scam by schools to get money by increasing student debt.

                • 6 votes
                #37
                 - government is always the answer :P
                 - 9:27 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                Yep, look at all the COLLEGE STUDENTS/GRADUATES this turkey is offering $100,000 NOT TO GO TO COLLEGE. Whatttt,,,,,,,,,Complete JOKE !!

                • 5 votes
                #38
                 - ldo
                 - 9:38 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                I have developed a way to cut out 20% of the total world use of 13 gallon household garbage bags. 20% less landfill and savings. Contact me

                • 2 votes
                #39
                 - Chexter
                 - 10:02 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                If people of this caliber are taking 50k a year they are underachievers!!!!!

                • 1 vote
                #40
                 - Benzzo76
                 - 10:07 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                I think this is ridiculous. Technology is mostly developed by the educated, not guys in their basements.

                • 1 vote
                #41
                 - Anarun-729769
                 - 10:15 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                these students are contradicting what the study is all about they already have college educations therefore, the study is invalid

                • 5 votes
                #42
                 - girl in california-3526999
                 - 10:31 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                Chosen few. Did these students ever have debt? He would never have given it to even straight-A's students. No altruism here!

                • 3 votes
                #43
                 - rjbbvcm
                 - 10:42 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                To many jobs require a certain level of college to work there. But in reality, short term OJT would benefit the job more.

                • 3 votes
                #44
                 - Barque
                 - 10:50 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                Thank you Theil; most of the college education is stifling the students creativity, put too much financial burden, with whimsical results.

                • 3 votes
                #45
                 - nazar younis
                 - 11:26 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                Let's not forget that Bill Gates is a college drop out. Opportunity and hands on may prove to be the way of the future.

                • 3 votes
                #46
                 - Tyrone E.
                 - 11:41 pm EDT on Wed May 25, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                Making money--good money--does not require a college degree...it requires know how...money savy.

                • 1 vote
                #47
                 - A Citizen-2845164
                 - 1:18 am EDT on Thu May 26, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                Even though this is a stunt, college has become less and less necessary. It is especially important to avoid student loan debt.

                • 5 votes
                #48
                 - magnets
                 - 2:43 am EDT on Thu May 26, 2011
                It's a stunt - these people don't represent most college students

                Tell an average person not to go to college and hand them $100k...see what happens then!

                • 3 votes
                #49
                 - Dustin-265090
                 - 3:21 am EDT on Thu May 26, 2011
                It's a great way to start debate about the value of college

                The academic world is as ossified and corrupt as any other traditional organization. This seems like a great way to spur innovation.

                  #50
                   - Will to Power
                   - 4:02 am EDT on Thu May 26, 2011
                  Jump to short comment page: 1 2

                  Comment

                  Show more
                  Explore related topics: education, college, dropouts, thiel-foundation
                • 18
                  May
                  2011
                  11:16am, EDT

                  Recent college grads hit by recession, survey shows

                  Most recent graduates are stuck taking lower-paying jobs that are less likely to offer health insurance, according to a Rutgers University poll.

                  Just over half of the 571 graduates of public and private four-year schools surveyed by the school have full-time jobs, while just under half said their first jobs didn’t really require bachelor’s degrees. Nearly half said their parents are helping them financially.

                  The college graduates in the poll left school between 2006 and 2010. The survey found that those who graduated between 2006 and 2008 fared better than those who graduated in 2009 or 2010. The earlier grads were paid about $3,000 a year more in their first jobs, and 88 percent of them received health insurance, compared with 77 percent of the more recent grads.

                  The findings of the poll were reported by the Associated Press.

                  Comment

                  Show more
                  Explore related topics: personal-finance, featured, jobs, college, health-insurance, pay
                Older posts

                Browse

                • featured,
                • economy,
                • employment,
                • business,
                • deals,
                • personal-finance,
                • good-graph-friday,
                • taxes,
                • unemployment,
                • live-chat,
                • buzz,
                • jobs,
                • retail,
                • cheapism,
                • careers,
                • retirement,
                • workplace,
                • money,
                • recession,
                • education,
                • real-estate,
                • career,
                • consumerman,
                • food,
                • consumer-news,
                • college,
                • median,
                • shopping,
                • housing,
                • autos,
                • women,
                • video,
                • investing,
                • facebook,
                • debt,
                • social-security,
                • pay,
                • gas-prices,
                • wealth,
                • holiday-retail,
                • work,
                • money-911,
                • finances
                Also

                Top TODAY.com headlines

                3155,10
                Advertise | AdChoices

                Eve Tahmincioglu

                Eve Tahmincioglu writes the popular "Your Career" column for MSNBC.com and her blog www.careerdiva.net, covers a broad range of career and labor issues. Her blog was named one of the top ten career blogs by Forbes, US News & World Report and CareerBuilder. Last year, she was named one of the top online business columnist in the country by the Society of American Business Editors and Writers. She's al …

                Let's Connect
                Follow me on Twitter at Twitter.com/Careerdiva.

                Martin Wolk

                Martin Wolk is the executive business editor of msnbc.com, responsible for business content on the msnbc digital network. Prior to joining msnbc in 1999, he worked as a correspondent for Reuters in Seattle and New York. He is based in Redmond, Wash.

                Martin Wolk Blogroll

                • The Big Picture
                • Business Insider
                • Economix
                • Freakonomics
                • The Consumerist
                • Seeking Alpha
                • Planet Money
                • Money Blog
                • DealBook
                • Bloomberg Businessweek
                • Forbes.com
                Twitter
                Follow @martywolk

                Allison Linn

                Allison Linn is the lead writer for TODAY Money's Life Inc. She also writes about the economy, consumer issues, personal finance, employment and workplace issues for msnbc.com. Linn joined msnbc.com from The Associated Press, where she mainly covered Microsoft. Previously, she worked at newspapers in Colorado, Washington and Oregon. She also spent nearly two years as a reporter in Germany.

                Allison Linn Blogroll

                • Career Diva
                • Consumer Reports Money
                • Floyd Norris
                • The Big Picture
                • The Consumerist
                • The Juggle
                • Suddenly Frugal
                • Consumer Reports Baby & Kids
                • The Economist Free Exchange
                • Bucks
                • Brazen Careerist
                • On the Job
                Let's socialize!
                Want more Life Inc.? Follow me on Twitter, check us out on Facebook or send me your news tips or story ideas.

                Anika Anand

                After graduating with a journalism degree from UNC-Chapel Hill last May, I moved to New York to try to find someone to pay me to be a journalist. I was fairly successful, and completed internships with Salon.com and Business Insider, which both helped me realize I want to work in business journalism.

                Rob Neill

                Msnbc.com producer who has worked on sports, entertainment, travel, news, cover and now the business desk. Yes, I realize I may have trouble keeping a job.

                Rob Neill Blogroll

                • sactown royalty
                • Fark
                • The Drams
                • Clusterstock
                • Business Insider
                • Digital daily

                Archives

                • 2012
                  • May (32)
                  • April (62)
                  • March (77)
                  • February (69)
                  • January (48)
                • 2011
                  • December (62)
                  • November (69)
                  • October (63)
                  • September (62)
                  • August (58)
                  • July (54)
                  • June (42)
                  • May (48)
                  • April (43)
                  • March (47)
                  • February (36)
                  • January (43)
                • 2010
                  • December (65)
                  • November (64)
                  • October (51)
                  • September (43)
                  • August (16)

                Most Commented

                • Long-term unemployed losing benefits as job picture improves (1578)
                • Want economic success? New Jersey's better than Oklahoma (370)
                • For women in the workplace, it's still about looks not deeds (165)
                • Where are all the powerful female nerds? (94)
                • Want a job? You have 60 seconds to convince me (66)
                • Men, women worry about unemployment differently (46)
                • Employee perks good for employers, too, study suggests (46)
                • To get a job, consider a business degree (32)

                Other blogs

                • allDAY
                • Animal Tracks
                • Bites
                • The Clicker
                • Digital Life
                • Hip2Save
                • Kathie Lee and Hoda
                • Life Inc.
                • The Look
                • TODAY Entertainment
                • TODAY Moms
                • TODAY on the Trail

                More on TODAY.com

                3155,8
                © 2012 msnbc.com
                • Today.com Money
                • About us
                • Contact
                • Help
                • Site map
                • Careers
                • Terms & Conditions
                • MSN Privacy
                • Legal
                • Advertise
                Advertise | AdChoices